May
11

It’s time to “formally” close this campaign blog

It’s time to “formally” close this campaign blog. It was always about the campaign. I will return to blogging soon but somewhere new.

Losing last week was a painful experience. But that’s the joy of the democratic process and I have no complaints. No-one forced me to sign up for this and I always knew that this was one possible scenario…

I owe my wonderful team a great debt of gratitude for working so hard and for being so committed to the cause. Led by my campaign manager, the phenomenon that is Kez Dugdale MSP, (her election is one wee bright light in an otherwise dark few days) and my great friend and agent Ian Perry,(who will never look a window envelope in the eye again), we managed to buck the trend and increase the Labour share of the vote but it was not enough. It felt a bit like scoring a hat-trick in the cup final and still being on the loosing side. My deepest thanks to all my team and to everyone who offered so very much support to me over the campaign. Thanks too to all of you who have read my musings here over the last months.

Nationally our results were worse than disastrous.  Scottish Labour lost so badly for many reasons; here are my thoughts about some of the self inflicted ones -

  • We assumed that there were some un-assailable seats that would always be Labour – lesson; never take the people for granted
  • We all knew why we thought Scotland would be better led by Scottish Labour but we never explained why in the straightforward language of the living room. Where we had good ideas (e.g. 1000 literacy teachers, One plus support for small businesses, first foot fund for first time buyers – we spoke about numbers not lives changed or over explained and qualified rather than kept it simple and clear) – lesson; a good idea badly explained becomes a bad idea
  • There was no coherent value based threads woven through our policies or our manifesto. Politics has to be about values otherwise it doesn’t touch people’s hearts as well as their heads – lesson; our message didn’t touch the peoples souls, we need a consistent set of messages woven together in stories and metaphors that draw people into a common journey with us
  • We chose to ignore the our opposition but instead of that making them irrelevant as was the intention, it  gave them space on the park to control the game;  lesson If we want to fight for Scotland we need to fight in Scotland about Scotland facing the politicans of Scotland

And then the SNP played a blinder and the Libdems died the death of a thousand coalition cuts whilst the Tories flatlined. Whatever I think about their political ambitions, the SNP are to be congratulated on their achievement. Scottish Labour needs to take the time to reflect, review and rediscover that fire in our bellies that meant we spoke for those who are voiceless and stand for those who are forgotten. And then make sure we really are doing so

And what next for me – who knows; but there is one final wee story. Apparently at 5.20am on Thursday morning, few moments after the announcement of the Edinburgh Eastern result,there was a huge power surge in my workplace at 121 George Street, (HQ of the Church of Scotland),blowing all the lights and then a tank was seen rolling down the street towards Bute House; for some reason my colleagues seem to think that this was a sign of something but they can’t quite work out what – anyone got any suggestions?!!!

May
05

Now its in the hands of the voters….

And so it’s the big day.  I began this journey when I started canvassing for Sheila  Gilmore MP in June 2009 and since then I have talked personally with literally 1000;s of voters.  That in itself has been a great gift and I know that I better understand many things about the city and its citizens because of those conversations.

Of course, what now happens lies not in my hands but in the hands of those same voters.  I know what I hope they choose to do but in the end it will be them and them alone who decides who represents them I the Scottish Parliament for the next 5 years.  In a week when the whole debate about democracy, sovereignty and justice was exposed and challenged in the death of one many in a city far way, I am deeply grateful and humbled that I have been able to be a candidate ion a democratic process where we can agree or disagree without being disagreeable – or shot.

Whatever happens, I have been reminded again and again just how precious a thing our democracy is and why it is important that we make sure as many folk as possible engage in its processes- whether or not that means they vote for me or my Party.

 

May
03

The doorstep is where this election will be won and lost

9 hours on the doors yesterday and I am footsore and sun-burnt; but very happy.  I had many conversations with a huge number of people, (most referred to topic; the economy, second most referred to topic, (or so it felt like!) dog fouling! Most obscure topic; a wedding I did 15 years ago, topic which generated the most passion – what does the future hold for young people?) I find this part of campaigning the most enjoyable. Even the folk who disagree with me are part of the buzz of face to face campaigning.

Folk were bemused by the announcement that the SNP are no longer going to bring in a local income tax; after spending £80,000 of our money to hide its real effects, that is quite a U turn.  What I am also hearing is that folk do not believe that a Government concentrating on independence by 2018 is what Scotland needs right now. And with recent figures showing that independence would cost £13.75b, that argument is taking hold on the doorsteps big time. And its on the doorsteps that I will be right up until the close of polls on Thursday……

May
02

An extraordinary moment

The extraordinary breaking news of the death of Osama Bin Laden eclipses anything else I might have wanted to talk about.  The death of that one individual in a two story house in Abbotabad Pakistan, 30 miles from Islamabad will have political and probably military ramifications for many years to some.

I understand why folk are reacting as they have and would not criticise them for doing so, but my first thought is that no matter what he did or inspired to be done in bringing about the deaths of many people, it remains a disconcerting thought that there are celebrations over the death of another human being, brought about, in this case, by a state of which he was not a national or within whose borders he was not  living or had ever lived.

There is for many the possibility of a sense of closure for many, and a feeling that “justice has been done”  and these are good things. But as many have said, whilst this is a symbolic moment it does not symbolise the end of the “war on terror”. In fact, over the next few months we need to be even more vigilant.

The death of Osama Bin Laden does not make the world a more secure place.  That will only come about when the relationships between East and West have been healed and that is a far longer journey, one that will require a very different kind of communication and conversation, a journey where the travellers need not only to understand the others on the journey but to better understand themselves as well. This has to be a journey that begins with a sense of our common humanity, rather than our differences or who is more powerful or even who is “right” or “wrong” about what the nature and purpose of the human condition. That’s is a journey for which that last nights events are no more than one step and maybe not even that.

May
01

The planet needs us to live more lightly

I had a long conversation about the environment with a young couple yesterday right at the end of a very successful day on the doors.  For them the environment is the issue that politicians need to grapple with but they questioned the commitment of the 4 main parties to the issue.

I told them that I believe that there is no greater issue for politicians of all parties to grapple with than the environment and global warming. It will affect all that we do and all that we are and we don’t have much time to get it right. I also believe however, that even if the climate change deniers are right , (and I don’t for a minute think that they are!), the world is a precious thing and we should learn to live on it much more lightly than we do for its own sake and ours.

I have tried to do this myself in a number of ways:

When I was leader of the Council I made sure that Edinburgh was the first Council to sign up to the 2050 local authority Zero Carbon Emissions commitment.  Scotland’s Capital needs to lead by example.

For the last three years I have been chair of Eco Congregations Scotland, an ecumenical organisation made up of over 260 congregations all over Scotland committed to changing their lives as a faith community to a more environmentally friendly lifestyle and being a catalyst for change in the wider community for the same objective.

I put a great deal of effort in because I believe that its is a huge priority to get communities active, aware and responding.

Eco Congregation Scotland was instrumental in lobbying amending the Climate Change Act (Scotland) to include a community engagement strategy because I believe that only by creating a movement that is bottom up as well as top down can we reach our objectives of carbon reduction. Eco Congregation Scotland is a significant participant is the Stop Climate Chaos Scotland  (SCCS) a civic society coalition that has had such a significant influence on political and civic debate in Scotland over the last 5 years.

For example, I reflected on the fact that even since the last election, “green issues” if I can use that short hand, have shot right up the agenda of all the political parties and SCCS can take a large part of the credit for that.

Scottish Labour has put the environment front and centre. We would;

  • Implement a Green New Deal to tackle fuel poverty and drive down carbon emissions, offering whole-house energy efficient retrofits and creating micro-generation opportunities for 10,000 homes and businesses, creating jobs, trainee-ships and business opportunities for local firms across Scotland.
  • Set the expectation that green procurement is the norm, particularly for food provision, and help to generate new markets and supply chains for low carbon products.
  • End fuel poverty by 2016 by target resources at the most fuel-poor, especially older and more vulnerable people and continuing to invest in measures to reduce fuel poverty and reviewing the effectiveness of the Energy Assistance Package and the Home Insulation Scheme.
  • Make walking and cycling become a more convenient, attractive and realistic choice for many short journeys and will retain the target of ensuring that 10 per cent of trips be made by bike by 2020. To achieve this, we will ensure that active travel receives a higher proportion of the overall transport budget

In addition we would prioritise the environmental agenda by ;

  • Making best use the new feed-in tariff to promote the expansion of household renewables and investigate further council tax discounts, grants and incentives for householders and businesses who make green changes.
  • Making Scotland is a net exporter of electricity to the rest of the UK, with a target of at least 80 per cent of our electricity to come from renewables by 2020.
  • Creating 10,000 pints for electric cars
  • Setting up Energy Scotland to drive forward Scotland as a renewables world leader.
  • Seeking to expedite applications for new renewable energy developments within nine months of them being lodged.
  • Creating a policy framework to further encourage private sector investment in offshore wind, wave and tidal power.
  • Supporting the continuing contribution of the offshore oil and gas industry to our economy, whilst also seeking the transfer of skills and expertise in offshore renewable.
  • Commit to doubling the Saltire Prize.
  • Increasing the production, distribution and use of community-scale heat and power,
  • Continuing Energy Savings Trust loan scheme to allow businesses and local authorities to take advantage of cost-effective opportunities.
  • Recognise that local bulk purchasing leads to lower prices; support community organisations, co-ops and social enterprises who pursue community renewable projects.
  • Requiring local authorities to produce heat maps, to assist in the identification of potential community and public renewable heat schemes.
  • Increasing energy efficiency within our energy system and will tackle heat loss in energy generation by seeking to introduce schemes to capture and use surplus heat from the power stations via new ‘smart’ heat grids.
  • Supporting of the development of renewables in Scottish Water’s estate, and will enhance powers so that it can fulfil its renewable energy potential and use its assets more effectively.
  • Not consenting to new, non- replacement fossil-fired power stations unless they can demonstrate effective carbon capture and storage technology from the outset

It’s a huge agenda covering a great many bases, but it needs to be.  “Green issues” are no longer some nice wee add on, (not that they ever were, but they were treated as such).  They have to be the driver for the next 20 plus years or the consequences will be much more dramatic than who will win or loose an election!

Apr
30

Doorstep inspirations

Doorstep conversations cover the whole spectrum from the very supportive to the down right rude.  In between there are the apathetic, the inquisitive, the doubtful, the cautious, the surprised and many more.  Then, every so often, there is the inspirational conversation.  Last night I had one of the inspirational ones.

I was at the door of a nursery nurse who laid it on the line about education.  What was wrong and what could be right. And she talked a lot of sense

Her plan for education was;

  • Involve more people more often in resourcing interventions across the board in 0 – 5 services, especially health visitors – be brave about intervening because by the time kids get to 8 or 9 bad behavior patterns are much more difficult to change
  • Give nursery nurses space to be nursery nurses and value their experience and insights
  • Develop a system of accountability that trusts staff and uses evidence other than paperwork and one short visit
  • Use nursery nurses in the transition between nursery and primary one (i.e. have them working with the P1’s)
  • Let Curriculum for Excellence flourish by reducing outcomes from the top

She spoke of other things too but I think these points give you an idea of her thinking.  I promised to go back to see her after the election.  She inspired me and I don’t want to loose that inspiration and wisdom.

Apr
29

The choice on May 5th is now clear

The SNP have finally admitted that they want to be independence front and centre in this campaign. with the confession that they want independence by 2018 It has been a bizarre kind of phoney war so far with the SNP playing down their one big policy of independence because they know the voters don’t want it and instead have played a “we did sort of alright in Government so gonna gies another chance” but now the truth is out. Even tonight at what was our 4th hustings, when my SNP opponent was asked what he wished for Scotland he didn’t use the independence word, despite having plenty of chance to do so, instead he said “we have done ok in Government”.  Done ok… since when was that good enough for Scotland….!

This election comes down to a key choice; does Scotland need, right now, a Government focused on independence or a Government focused on the economy? Do we need some-one saying lets break up the union or do we need a Government saying how to get more jobs created for young people?  Do we need some-one saying lets have a discussion about what currency we need for Scotland or discussing where best to invest in public services and to support business and innovation?  I am sure that the voters know the answers and will let the SNP know on May 5th…

Apr
28

Erskine House – an inspiration

Spent a fascinating morning at the Erskine Home for Service Veterans yesterday  The dedication of the staff and the stories of the residents made it an inspiring experience.

The folk we met were older people, veterans of wars gone by.,  Sadly, there are ”new veterans” being created every day. My team met one lad, (for that was what he was) on the doors one day – a war veteran with a lifetime of disability ahead – aged 21….   I know that when I was 21, the idea of being in a war and facing death or disability on a daily basis was probably beyond my capacity to cope with,  Yet we ask these young men and women to do this all the time.

I know that war is sometimes all we have left.  That doesn’t make it right or good, just the least bad thing our fragile humanity has to offer some circumstances.  But when those wars loose their way, (Afghanistan, Iraq) or subtle shifts in purpose for saving civilians to saying the only way to save civilians is regime change (Libya) then I fear even that least bad model isn’t good enough.

We need honesty, transparency, consistency and caution before we go to war and we need accountability and constant review when we aer at war to make sure we don’t cross the line from saving others to promoting ourselves

I am glad we have Erskine House and the many other veterans support groups that serve those who have served. They are a sign of humanity at its very best.  The best thing we could do however, is make sure that we minimise the need for their services in future years by not taking decisions that increase the number of veterans who need their care any more than we have to.

Apr
27

Political life is a privilege and a gift

Spent much of yesterday on the doors again and will do the same today.  It’s such a core task and cannot be overdone. And the response is very good. As I l keep telling the journalists “I am not behind, I may not be ahead, but I am not behind.”

As well as hearing peoples views on the election, its amazing the glimpses you are allowed into peoples lives that would otherwise be hidden.  Like the woman who began to talk about how her husband had died 3 weeks ago and how empty the house was.  Or the man who had just been diagnosed with dementia who said “the hardest thing is knowing that one day I won’t know”. Or the woman who just spilled out words to me about the struggles she was facing with her divorce.

These moments are a privilege but also a reminder that if politics is to be about people rather than simply policies and ideology, then it has to be a much more complex journey than it is often given the space to be.  There are things we as politicians can do to help alleviate the situation these folk face.  But we cannot solve the problems, nor can we stop them happening. Politics is about all of life, but it can never be about all the answers. It can however, be rooted in real life if we listen to the stories have the privilege of being gifted and we take the time to be there to hear them

Apr
26

School’s back… but to what future?

Kids back at school so the early morning routine has had to be rediscovered – went surprisingly smoothly this morning it has to be said – but will it last?!

What won’t last is morale in schools, which, if the teachers I talk to are accurate in their staff room stories, is at an all time low.  All the progress made on early intervention, support for literacy, one to one support by learning assistants, the removal of specialist services and specific and much more is being lost to the cuts.   Class sizes are increasing, there are fewer teachers and the removal of bursars and other “backroom staff” brings more pressure, more work and less efficiency and a sense that the bottom line is driving policy more and more.

And all adding to the increased fears across the nation that the potential that is curriculum for excellence will be being lost to the battle over cuts and false economies. And all this with not one new school being commissioned or built under the SNP administration.

It is a tragic indictment on their lack of ability to do what they said they would do and a real danger that this will damage not only the opportunities of present day pupils but a whole generation.  It cannot be allowed to happen.

 

Older posts «

Social Buttons by Linksku